Winning Battles but Losing the War: The Strategic Imperative of Succession Planning for Business Owners

In the theater of business, much like on the battlefield, strategy is everything. Over the next decade, an estimated 12 million businesses are projected to change hands—a number expected to rise as time marches on. For most business owners, the ultimate objective—the "war"—is to sell their enterprise at its full appraised value, securing a prosperous retirement. They've won countless "battles" by building successful companies, conquering market share, and achieving profitability. Yet, without a well-planned exit strategy, many are poised to lose the war.

Just as a military commander wouldn't dream of entering a campaign without a clear plan for victory and withdrawal, business owners must prepare for the eventual transition of their companies. Unfortunately, a significant number are ill-prepared for this critical phase. Without proper succession planning, they risk retreating from the marketplace without the spoils of victory they worked so hard to earn.

Statistics reveal a concerning trend: approximately two-thirds of business owners are not ready to sell within the next 10 to 15 years, even though this period presents a prime opportunity with potentially high profit margins. This scenario mirrors an army that has won every skirmish but faces defeat in the final battle due to a lack of overarching strategy. Estimates suggest that around 5 million firms, collectively holding over $10 trillion in assets, will transition to new owners in the coming years. Yet, only about 20% to 30% of businesses that enter the market will successfully complete a sale. In other words, only a quarter of these "troops" will achieve ultimate victory, while the rest may falter due to insufficient preparation.

Private equity firms and strategic buyers are like generals seeking to ally with strong forces; they're eager to find valuable acquisitions but struggle due to a lack of well-prepared candidates. The demand is strong, but the supply is not battle-ready. This imbalance is akin to a well-equipped army ready for engagement but finding no worthy allies on the field.

Baby boomers—the seasoned veterans in the business world—are holding onto their "fortresses" longer than previous generations. Accustomed to the steady "supply lines" of cash flow, they're hesitant to "withdraw their forces" unless necessity or unforeseen "crisis" forces their hand. Many are expected to sell in their early 70s, delaying the "troop movements" that could secure their legacy and financial future.

A critical misstep for many is delaying the initiation of exit planning. Like a commander who postpones strategizing until the enemy is at the gates, business owners who wait too long face significant obstacles in "negotiating terms of surrender" that are favorable to them. Without a thorough and realistic appraisal—taking into account "terrain changes" like inflation and economic shifts—they may overvalue their business, repelling potential buyers, or undervalue it, leaving substantial wealth on the table.

Some owners rely on optimistic "battle plans," basing their valuations on projected revenues or hopeful market conditions, rather than solid "intelligence" from actual cash flow and profitability. This approach is as perilous as a general planning an offensive based on wishful thinking rather than reliable reconnaissance, leading to potential defeat.

To avoid losing the war after winning so many battles, business owners must engage in strategic succession planning. Seeking professional guidance from accountants, financial advisors, and business valuation experts is crucial—much like a commander consulting with strategists and advisors to plan a successful campaign. Tax returns alone won't provide the necessary insights. Owners need a comprehensive "battle map" to fully understand the true value of their enterprise and navigate the complex terrain of selling a business.

By educating themselves and assembling a team of experts, business owners can formulate a winning exit strategy. This proactive approach ensures they not only win individual battles but also secure ultimate victory in the war for their financial future, leaving a lasting legacy and reaping the full rewards of their lifelong efforts.

Never Miss an Opportunity:

SUBSCRIBE TO THE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER (FREE)

Receive Exclusive Content and Business Cases:

SUBSCRIBE FOR ONLY $5 TO UNLIMITED & SPECIALIZED CONTENT

Showcase your Expertise to 100,000 Middle Market Business owners and executives

BECOME A CONTRIBUTOR, APPLY NOW

Join the most network for middle market experts and leaders

BECOME A MEMBER (COMING SOON) - LAUNCH Q1 2025