Search Funds. How to capture the value from the Silver Tsunami.
Search Funds as a Pillar of ETA: Entrepreneurship Through Acquisition
Search funds have emerged as a distinctive investment vehicle within the private equity landscape, offering a unique pathway for entrepreneurs to acquire and manage established businesses.
Search funds are part of a broader trend known as Entrepreneurship Through Acquisition (ETA), where aspiring entrepreneurs acquire existing businesses rather than starting new ventures. This approach has gained significant traction in recent years as a viable path to business ownership, offering a balance of reduced risk and entrepreneurial opportunity. ETA appeals to those who see value in building on an established foundation, such as a stable customer base, cash flow, and operational infrastructure, instead of starting from scratch.
This model not only facilitates entrepreneurial aspirations but also plays a pivotal role in the broader ecosystem of business acquisitions.
Defining Search Funds
A search fund is an investment structure where an entrepreneur, often referred to as a "searcher," raises capital from investors to identify, acquire, and operate a privately held company. Unlike traditional private equity funds that manage multiple investments, a search fund typically focuses on acquiring a single company, with the searcher assuming a direct management role post-acquisition.
Historical Origins
The concept of search funds was pioneered in 1984 by H. Irving Grousbeck, a professor at Stanford University's Graduate School of Business. Grousbeck's vision was to create a structured pathway for aspiring entrepreneurs to transition into business ownership by acquiring existing companies. Since its inception, the model has gained traction, particularly among MBA graduates from elite business schools, and has expanded globally.
Role in the Business Acquisition Ecosystem
Search funds occupy a unique niche in the business acquisition landscape, particularly in the lower middle market. They typically target companies with enterprise values ranging from $5 million to $50 million, focusing on businesses with sustainable market positions and stable cash flows. This focus addresses a segment often overlooked by larger private equity firms, thereby facilitating the transfer of ownership in small to medium-sized enterprises (SMEs).
For investors, search funds offer the opportunity to invest in a single, carefully selected company, with the added advantage of the searcher's commitment to operational leadership. This alignment of interests can lead to significant value creation. Notably, a 2022 analysis by Stanford's Center for Entrepreneurial Studies reported an aggregate pre-tax internal rate of return of 35.3% for search funds, underscoring their potential for substantial returns.
For entrepreneurs, search funds provide a viable route to business ownership without the inherent risks of starting a new venture. The model offers access to capital, mentorship from experienced investors, and the opportunity to lead an established company, making it an attractive alternative to traditional entrepreneurial paths.
The Investor's Perspective: Search Funds vs. Traditional Private Equity and Syndication
For limited partner (LP) investors, the choice between investing in a search fund, a traditional private equity (PE) fund, or a syndication/private placement involves nuanced considerations, particularly regarding risk, return, and operational involvement. Each model presents a unique approach to business acquisition and value creation.
Search Funds: A Targeted, Entrepreneur-Led Approach
Unlike traditional PE funds, search funds are not pooled investment vehicles for multiple acquisitions. Instead, they represent an alternative financing structure that enables a single entrepreneur (or a small team) to search for, acquire, and operate one established business. Investors in search funds gain exposure to:
Operational Focus: The searcher becomes the day-to-day operator post-acquisition, ensuring direct accountability and alignment of interests.
Return Dynamics: Returns are generated primarily from the growth and eventual sale of the acquired business. LPs in a search fund often realize their returns through dividends during ownership and a capital gain upon exit.
This model contrasts sharply with syndications or private placements, which focus on raising funds for a single transaction without the entrepreneur's commitment to operational leadership. In syndications, the focus is typically on passive returns, with limited influence on the operations of the business.
Traditional Private Equity: Diversification and Scalability
Traditional PE funds offer a diversified portfolio of investments, spreading risk across multiple companies or projects. This diversification appeals to LPs seeking stable returns and reduced exposure to single-asset risks.
Operational Model: PE firms rarely operate portfolio companies directly. Instead, they rely on hired executives and management teams to implement growth strategies, restructuring, or value creation initiatives.
Capital Return: PE funds often return capital to LPs through periodic distributions from portfolio company exits, recapitalizations, or dividends. The structured timelines (e.g., 10-year fund lives) ensure a predictable cadence of capital deployment and return.
Search funds lack this diversification, focusing instead on the success of one targeted company, which may result in higher volatility but also the potential for outsized returns due to concentrated efforts and entrepreneurial leadership.
Search Funds as an Alternative Financing Structure
Rather than being a traditional private equity vehicle, search funds occupy a distinct category of alternative financing. They cater to entrepreneurs with the ambition to acquire and lead a business, often targeting lower middle-market firms. LPs in search funds effectively back the entrepreneur, not just the asset, which makes these investments highly personalized and dependent on the searcher's skills and commitment.
Operational Differences and Investor Considerations
Day-to-Day Operations
Search Funds: Post-acquisition, the searcher transitions into the CEO role, managing operations directly and implementing growth strategies hands-on. This active involvement allows for agile decision-making and close alignment with the business’s needs.
Traditional PE Funds: Portfolio companies are typically managed by professional executives or existing leadership teams, with the PE firm providing strategic oversight through board representation and financial engineering.
Capital Return Mechanisms
Search Funds: Returns hinge on the successful operation and eventual sale of the acquired business, with limited interim distributions. Investors typically wait several years for liquidity events.
Traditional PE Funds: Diversified investment timelines and strategies enable more frequent distributions, often derived from multiple portfolio company exits or refinancing activities.
Syndication/Private Placement: These rely on specific exit strategies or revenue-sharing arrangements tied to a single project or transaction, offering more variable timelines for capital return.
The Social Dynamics of Searchers
The success of a search fund hinges largely on the profile of the searcher, the entrepreneur driving the acquisition and eventual management of the business. The social dynamics surrounding searchers often reveal patterns in their backgrounds, motivations, and leadership styles:
Educational Background: Many searchers are MBA graduates from elite business schools, where they gain access to resources, mentorship, and networks critical to the search process.
Professional Experience: Searchers typically have strong prior experience in consulting, investment banking, or management roles, providing them with analytical and strategic capabilities essential for identifying and scaling a target company.
Personal Characteristics: Successful searchers are often characterized by their resilience, resourcefulness, and relationship-building skills. They must navigate the uncertainty of the search phase and inspire confidence among investors, sellers, and employees.
These dynamics are as much about the individual’s personality as their credentials. Search funds demand a unique combination of entrepreneurial spirit, operational grit, and interpersonal finesse to navigate the complexities of acquiring and managing a business.
Determining the Best Searcher Profile
For LPs evaluating potential searchers, assessing fit is critical. The best searchers exhibit a blend of analytical rigor, leadership qualities, and a deep commitment to their entrepreneurial journey. Key attributes to look for include:
Strategic Vision: The ability to articulate a clear investment thesis and a targeted approach for identifying acquisition opportunities.
Operational Aptitude: Proven leadership experience or evidence of a steep learning curve in managing teams and systems.
Network and Resources: Access to a robust network of advisors, mentors, and industry experts to support the search and operational phases.
Resilience: A demonstrated track record of overcoming obstacles, crucial for navigating the challenges of the search process and post-acquisition growth.
What LPs Should Consider
LPs investing in search funds must carefully evaluate the alignment between the searcher’s profile and their own risk tolerance and investment strategy. Specific considerations include:
Searcher Commitment: Does the searcher demonstrate the drive and focus needed to sustain a rigorous search and operational management?
Deal Sourcing Plan: Does the searcher have a clear strategy for sourcing deals, and do they understand the industries they are targeting?
Alignment of Interests: Does the searcher have meaningful “skin in the game” to ensure alignment with investors?
Cultural Fit: Can the searcher effectively connect with sellers, employees, and stakeholders to create trust and goodwill?
INSIGHT: Search Funds in the Era of ETA
As an alternative financing structure, search funds embody the essence of ETA, providing aspiring entrepreneurs with a structured path to business ownership. Their rise reflects a shift in how entrepreneurship is perceived—leveraging acquisition as a means to enter established markets and create value.
For LPs, search funds offer an opportunity to invest in talented, driven individuals who can combine entrepreneurial ambition with disciplined management to achieve growth. By carefully evaluating the social dynamics and profiles of searchers, investors can identify promising opportunities while mitigating risks, ensuring their capital supports not only financial returns but also the broader impact of fostering the next generation of entrepreneurial leaders.
I hope this helps! ❤️
Book Your Strategy Call: https://tidycal.com/tashsalas/discovery-call-middle-market-growth-and-exit
Access for free our Directory of Middle Market Experts. Go to: https://middlemarketjournal.com/experts-middle-market
Are you a Middle Market Expert? Apply at: https://middlemarketjournal.com/expert-invitation
If you're an American company looking for growth capital over $10 million, you cannot miss the Alternative Financing and Investment Tour, an initiative to connect middle-market companies in national priority sectors with private and institutional investors.
Submit your proposal or request for Funding and Partnerships
Mind Your Own Business
Subscribe to our exclusive content for only $15:
https://middlemarketjournal.com/journal-new-subscription
Become part of our Network of business owners, experts, and investors!
